Stock Options vs Restricted Stock: The Key Differences for High-Earning Families

By Kevin Luu, Co-Founder and Chief Learning Officer. Reviewed on 2026-09-30.

The difference between stock options and restricted stock is what you receive and when you pay tax. Restricted stock (or a restricted stock unit, RSU) gives you shares outright once they vest, so it is worth something as long as the share price is above zero, and it is taxed as wages at vest. A stock option gives you the right to buy shares at a fixed strike price, so it is only worth the gap between the share price and the strike, it costs cash to exercise, and the tax depends on whether it is a nonqualified option (NSO) or an incentive stock option (ISO).

For a two-earner family in the Bay Area or Seattle, the type of grant drives three practical things: how much cash you need, how much tax is due and in which year, and how much of your net worth ends up tied to one employer. Below is how each type works, a side-by-side table, a worked example at a $900,000 household income, and the decisions you actually have to make.

Three different grants that people call “restricted stock”

The words get used loosely, so it helps to separate them first.

  • Restricted stock award (RSA). Actual shares issued to you on day one, subject to a vesting schedule. If you leave early, the company can take back or repurchase the unvested shares. Common at early-stage startups, where shares are cheap. Because you own real shares, you usually get voting rights and dividends during vesting.
  • Restricted stock unit (RSU). A promise to deliver shares (or cash) when the units vest. Nothing is issued until vest, so there is no voting and usually only dividend equivalents, if any. This is what most public tech and biotech employers grant. See RSU vs common stock for how vested RSU shares compare with ordinary shares.
  • Restricted securities under SEC rules. A separate, securities-law meaning: shares acquired in an unregistered sale (for example, private company stock) that can only be resold under conditions such as SEC Rule 144. “Control securities” are shares held by an affiliate, such as an executive officer, director or large shareholder. This is about when you may sell, not how you are taxed (SEC, Rule 144).

Stock options come in two tax types. NSOs can be granted to anyone, including advisers and board members (so-called “advisory shares” are usually NSOs or RSAs, not a separate legal category). ISOs can only go to employees and carry special tax rules (IRC §422).

Side-by-side: RSUs, restricted stock awards, NSOs and ISOs

RSU Restricted stock award NSO ISO
What you get Shares delivered at vest Shares now, forfeitable until vest Right to buy at strike price Right to buy at strike price
Cash needed None Sometimes a purchase price Strike price plus tax at exercise Strike price (and possibly AMT)
Value if stock falls Lower, but rarely zero Lower, but rarely zero Zero if price is below strike Zero if price is below strike
Main taxable event Vest/delivery, as wages Vest, as wages (or grant, with 83(b)) Exercise, spread taxed as wages Sale; spread counts for AMT at exercise
83(b) election Not available Available, within 30 days Only if early-exercised unvested Only if early-exercised unvested
Voting and dividends before vest No Usually yes No No

Sources for the tax rows: IRS Publication 525 (restricted property, stock options) and Treas. Reg. §1.83-3(e), which is why an RSU, an unfunded promise, is not “property” you can make an 83(b) election on.

How each one is taxed

RSUs: wages at vest, with withholding that is often too low

When RSUs vest and shares are delivered, the full market value is wage income on your W-2, subject to income tax, Medicare and (until you pass the wage base) Social Security. For 2026, employers commonly withhold federal income tax at the 22% supplemental rate, and must withhold 37% on supplemental wages above $1,000,000 in the calendar year (IRS Publication 15). For a household in the 35% or 37% bracket, 22% withholding usually leaves a balance due in April. More on that in withhold to cover vs sell to cover. RSUs have no strike price, which is the whole reason they hold value in a down market (do RSUs have a strike price?).

Restricted stock awards: the 83(b) choice

Without an election, an RSA is taxed like an RSU: wages at vest, on the value at that time. With a Section 83(b) election, filed with the IRS within 30 days after the shares are transferred to you, you are taxed now on the value at grant (often close to zero at a young startup), and later growth is capital gain when you sell (Pub 525). The risk: if you leave before vesting and forfeit the shares, you generally cannot deduct the tax you paid on the election. Our 83(b) election letter guide walks through the filing.

NSOs: wages at exercise

No tax at grant or vest. When you exercise, the spread (market price minus strike price) is wage income, and later growth from that point is capital gain. Many people exercise and sell on the same day to avoid fronting cash; see tax on cashless exercise.

ISOs: no regular tax at exercise, but AMT exposure

Exercising an ISO creates no regular income tax, but the spread is an adjustment for the alternative minimum tax. If you hold the shares more than 2 years from grant and more than 1 year from exercise, the whole gain over the strike is long-term capital gain; sell earlier and the gain, up to the spread at exercise, is ordinary income reported as wages (Pub 525). Only the first $100,000 of ISOs (by grant-date value) that become exercisable in a calendar year keep ISO status; the excess is treated as NSOs (IRC §422(d)).

The AMT point matters more at this income level since 2026. The married-filing-jointly AMT exemption is $140,200 for 2026, and it now phases out at 50 cents per dollar once AMT income passes $1,000,000, disappearing entirely at $1,280,400 (Rev. Proc. 2025-32; P.L. 119-21). A household earning $900,000 that exercises a large ISO block can land squarely in that phase-out.

Worked example: the same $200,000 in a California household

Assumptions (illustrative): married filing jointly, California residents, $900,000 of combined W-2 income, about $700,000 of federal and California taxable income before the equity event, each spouse already past the 2026 Social Security wage base ($184,500), and combined wages already above the $250,000 married-filing-jointly Additional Medicare Tax threshold. Each scenario adds $200,000 of value in 2026.

  1. RSUs: 1,000 RSUs vest at $200. Cash needed: none.
  2. NSOs: exercise 2,500 options with a $120 strike when the stock is $200. Spread $200,000. Cash needed: $300,000 to exercise, unless you sell some or all shares the same day.
  3. ISOs: same 2,500 options, but ISOs, held after exercise. Cash needed: $300,000. No regular tax in 2026, but $200,000 is added to AMT income.

For scenarios 1 and 2, the $200,000 is taxed the same way:

Tax on the $200,000 How it is calculated Amount
Federal income tax $68,700 at 35% (up to $768,700) plus $131,300 at 37% (2026 brackets) $72,626
Medicare 1.45% plus 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax $4,700
California income tax 9.3%, 10.3% and 11.3% bands (2025 schedule; 2026 not yet published) about $20,255
California SDI 1.3% of wages, no cap (2026) $2,600
Total about $100,181 (50%)
Federal withheld at 22% Supplemental rate $44,000
Federal shortfall $72,626 minus $44,000 $28,626

The RSU family owes this without having spent anything to get the shares. The NSO family owes the same tax and also had to find $300,000 for the strike, or sell shares to cover it. The ISO family pays no regular tax in 2026, but the $200,000 spread pushes their AMT income toward the $1,000,000 point where the 2026 exemption starts phasing out (a larger exercise would go past it), so a federal AMT projection before exercising is worth running. California also has its own alternative minimum tax, and the ISO spread is an adjustment there too (FTB Schedule P (540), 2025). Because California taxes capital gains as ordinary income (FTB), the ISO’s long-term holding period helps only on the federal return. Federally, the best case is that the gain is taxed at 20% plus the 3.8% net investment income tax instead of 37%.

The same family in Washington would owe no state income tax on the vest or the NSO spread in 2026, though the WA Cares long-term care premium (0.58% of wages, no cap) applies to that wage income for any spouse without an approved exemption (WA Cares Fund). If they later sold shares at a long-term gain, Washington’s capital gains tax applies at 7% to gains above the standard deduction ($278,000 for 2025, the latest published), rising to 9.9% on taxable gains above $1,000,000 (WA DOR). Washington has also enacted a 9.9% income tax on AGI over $1,000,000 starting January 1, 2028 (WA DOR), which will change this comparison for many Seattle-area equity earners.

The decisions that actually matter

  • RSUs: hold or sell at vest. Tax is already paid at vest, so holding vested RSUs is the same as buying your employer’s stock with a cash bonus. Ask whether you would buy that much today. Many families set a cap, such as no more than 10% of liquid net worth in one company, and sell the rest on a schedule.
  • NSOs: when to exercise. Exercising early starts the capital-gain clock but puts cash and tax at risk. Waiting keeps flexibility. Watch the expiration date and the post-termination exercise window if you change jobs.
  • ISOs: how many to exercise each year. Spreading exercises over several years can keep the AMT spread below the point where the exemption phases out.
  • Restricted stock awards: file the 83(b) or not. The election is most useful when the value at grant is low and you expect to stay. The 30-day window is fixed.
  • All of them: concentration. A household with $900,000 of income and $1.5 million of employer stock has its paycheck, bonus and savings riding on one company. Our investment risk management work starts there.

Common mistakes we see

  • Filing an 83(b) for RSUs. It does not apply; RSUs are not property until delivered.
  • Assuming the 22% withheld at vest covers the tax. In the example above it leaves about $28,626 owed federally on one $200,000 vest.
  • Treating ISOs as tax-free. The AMT can apply in the year of exercise, before you have sold anything.
  • Letting NSOs or ISOs expire after leaving a job because nobody tracked the post-termination window.
  • Comparing an offer of options with an offer of RSUs by share count. An option is worth only its spread, so 10,000 options and 10,000 RSUs are not comparable.

What to write down for your kids

Equity grants are where a lot of family wealth gets made, and where the reasoning is usually lost. Write a one-page Decision Memo each year: what you hold, what you sold, why, and what rule you followed (for example, “we sell RSUs at vest above a 10% cap”). Kept in a FamilyKnowledge® Library, those memos show your children how you weighed risk, taxes and loyalty to an employer, which is the part they cannot learn from a brokerage statement. As Kevin Luu puts it: “Your kids don’t need to inherit your portfolio. They need to inherit your decision-making process.” Our family governance work helps families set this up.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to get RSUs or stock options?

RSUs carry less risk: they keep value unless the stock goes to zero and need no cash to receive. Options can be worth more if the stock rises sharply, because each option gives leverage on the price move, but they can also end up worthless. At a large public company, RSUs are usually the steadier piece of pay. At an early-stage company, options or restricted stock offer more upside with more risk.

Do restricted stock and RSUs mean the same thing?

No. A restricted stock award issues real shares at grant, subject to forfeiture, and allows an 83(b) election. An RSU is a promise to deliver shares later, taxed as wages at delivery, with no 83(b) option. Public companies mostly grant RSUs; startups more often grant restricted stock or options in early rounds.

What happens to my options and RSUs if the company is acquired?

It depends on the merger agreement and your plan documents. Unvested awards may be converted into the buyer’s stock, cashed out, or accelerated, and underwater options are sometimes cancelled. See what happens to your stock if the company sells for the common outcomes.

Next step

Pull your grant summary from your stock plan portal and list each grant by type (RSU, RSA, NSO, ISO), vest dates and expiration dates. That one list answers most of the questions above. If you want help turning it into a tax plan for the year, our tax management team can model it in a Tax & Wealth Assessment.

This is general education, and the right move depends on your family’s full picture.

Kevin Luu, Co-Founder and Chief Learning Officer of Bright Advisers
Written by
Co-Founder and Chief Learning Officer, Bright Advisers

Kevin has advised high-income W-2 tech and biotech families since 2015, and leads the education-first Age Five Family Office from Brea, California.

Connect on LinkedIn →  · About Kevin

Table of Contents

Question 1 of 3

How much do you expect to pay in taxes this year?

Include federal, state, and local, just your best estimate.

A Under $150,000
B $150,000 – $199,999
C $200,000 – $299,999
D $300,000+
Question 2 of 3

What is your current annual household income?

Your typical annual income before taxes over the next few years.

A Under $750,000
B $750,000 – $999,999
C $1,000,000 – $2,999,999
D $3,000,000+
Question 3 of 3

Where does most of your income come from?

Choose all that apply. Focus on where ~80% of your income is taxed today.

✓ W-2 employee (salary, bonus, RSUs)
✓ Business owner (LLC, S-Corp, partnership)
✓ Rental / real estate
✓ Other
Your fit

Full assessment · 1 of 5

What does your current CPA relationship look like?

Be honest. This is where most of the opportunity hides.

A Tax preparation once a year
B Planning & preparation throughout the year
C I don't currently work with a CPA
Full assessment · 2 of 5

Have you ever had formal tax projections done?

Forward-looking modeling of your taxes, not just filing last year's return.

A Yes, recently
B Yes, but not in the last 2 years
C No
Full assessment · 3 of 5

Which strategies are you already using?

Choose all that apply.

✓ 401(k) / employer plan
✓ Backdoor Roth IRA
✓ Health Savings Account (HSA)
✓ Mega Backdoor Roth 401(k)
✓ Deferred Compensation
✓ Donor-Advised Fund
✓ None of these
Full assessment · 4 of 5

Do you have children under 18?

This opens up family-governance and generational planning strategies.

A Yes
B No
Full assessment · 5 of 5

If we showed you legal strategies that save more than they cost, would you act?

No pressure, this just helps us tailor your results.

A Yes, if the value is clear
B Maybe, I'd want to understand more
C Not right now
Almost done

Where should we send your full results?

We'll prepare your personalized savings breakdown and reach out to walk you through it.

Your information is private. Reviewed by an SEC-Registered Fiduciary (Bright Advisers, a DBA of Lifeworks Advisors, LLC · CRD# 288255).
Your results

estimated potential tax savings

    Kevin Luu

    "Thank you for taking the time. I've helped hundreds of high-earning families keep more of what they make, and from what you shared, I'm confident there's real opportunity here. I'll personally see you at our meeting."

    Kevin Luu · Co-Founder and Chief Learning Officer, Bright Advisers