By Kevin Luu, Co-Founder and Chief Learning Officer. Reviewed on 2026-09-30.
An assets under management (AUM) fee is a percentage of the money an adviser manages, charged every year and usually deducted straight from your accounts. A flat fee is a fixed dollar amount for a defined scope of work, whatever the portfolio is worth. For a high-income family with a growing portfolio, the real difference is not this year’s bill. It is how the two fees behave over the next 10 to 20 years, and what each one pays the adviser to care about.
This guide is written for dual-income W-2 families in California and Washington earning roughly $750,000 to $3 million, with RSUs, a 401(k) or two, 529s for young kids, and not much time. It shows how each fee model works, runs the numbers on a $3 million portfolio, and lists what to check before you sign.
How an assets under management fee is calculated
The adviser applies a percentage to the value of the accounts they manage, usually billed quarterly, in advance or in arrears. Most schedules are tiered: a higher rate on the first slice of assets and lower rates on the slices above it. The fee rises automatically as the portfolio grows, whether that growth came from markets or from you depositing vested RSUs and bonuses.
Three details change the real cost:
- Which accounts count. Some advisers bill only on accounts they hold at their custodian. Others bill on “assets under advisement” (AUA), which can include your 401(k), your company stock plan account, or cash they advise on but do not hold. Ask for the list in writing.
- Blended vs. cliff tiers. A blended schedule charges each rate only on its own slice. A cliff schedule applies one rate to the whole balance once you cross a threshold. The same headline numbers can produce very different bills.
- Costs on top of the fee. Fund expense ratios, custodian charges and trading costs are separate. The SEC’s Form ADV requires advisers to describe these other fees in their brochure (Form ADV Part 2, Item 5.C).
How a flat fee works
A flat-fee adviser quotes a fixed annual amount, often billed monthly or quarterly, for an agreed scope: investment management, tax planning, equity compensation, estate coordination, or some combination. The price is set by complexity (how many accounts, how much equity comp, whether there is a trust, how many tax decisions per year), not by the balance.
That makes the cost predictable from year to year. The trade-off is that the scope matters more. A flat fee that covers only portfolio management is not comparable to one that includes tax projections, RSU sale planning and coordination with your estate attorney.
What the SEC says about the incentive in each model
Both models are legal and both are common. What differs is the conflict each one creates. The SEC’s instructions for Form CRS, the short relationship summary advisers must give retail investors, give this example for asset-based fees: the more assets in the account, the more the investor pays, so the firm “may therefore have an incentive to encourage the retail investor to increase the assets in his or her account” (Form CRS instructions, Item 3).
For this reader, that incentive shows up in specific decisions:
- Paying down a mortgage, funding a 529 at another provider, or keeping cash for a home purchase all shrink billable assets.
- Holding concentrated company stock in your employer’s stock plan account keeps it outside the billed accounts, so there can be a quiet incentive to move it in rather than to decide what to do with it.
- Maxing out a 401(k), mega backdoor Roth or deferred compensation plan that the adviser does not bill on can look less attractive on their side of the table.
A flat fee removes the asset incentive but has its own: once the price is set, the adviser is paid the same whether they do more work or less. The fix is a written scope with named deliverables.
Separately, if an adviser or their staff earns commissions on products they recommend, the brochure must say so and explain the conflict (Form ADV Part 2, Item 5.E). “Fee-only” means no commissions. “Fee-based” usually means fees plus commissions.
Worked example: $3 million portfolio, flat fee vs. AUM over 20 years
Consider a Bay Area household: one parent is a physician, the other works at a biotech company. Combined W-2 income is about $1.1 million, including RSUs. They have $3 million in investable assets across a taxable brokerage account, two 401(k)s and 529s for two kids under 10. They are comparing two quotes.
Assumptions (illustrative, not market averages): AUM quote of 1.00% on the first $1 million, 0.80% on $1 million to $2 million, and 0.60% above $2 million, billed on the whole $3 million. Flat-fee quote of $24,000 a year, rising 3% a year. Portfolio grows 6% a year before fees. Fees are paid from the portfolio at year end. No new contributions.
| Year | AUM fee that year | Flat fee that year | Portfolio after AUM fees | Portfolio after flat fees |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $25,080 | $24,000 | $3,154,920 | $3,156,000 |
| 10 | $36,109 | $31,315 | $4,981,994 | $5,014,998 |
| 20 | $56,283 | $42,084 | $8,324,136 | $8,500,587 |
On the starting $3 million balance, both quotes work out to $24,000. Because the AUM fee in this example is charged on the year-end balance after growth, it is already $25,080 in year 1. Over 20 years, the family pays about $765,500 in AUM fees vs. about $644,900 in flat fees. Because the extra fees also stop compounding, the portfolio ends about $176,000 smaller under the AUM quote. If the family keeps adding RSU proceeds to the managed account, the gap widens, because every deposit raises the AUM fee and leaves the flat fee unchanged.
The math can also run the other way. A family with an $800,000 portfolio would pay about $8,000 a year at 1.00%, far less than a $24,000 flat fee. At that size, the question is whether the flat fee buys planning work (tax, equity comp, estate) the family actually needs. The break-even depends on the balance, the growth rate and the scope, so run your own numbers with both quotes side by side.
Are advisory fees tax-deductible in California or Washington?
Federally, no. Miscellaneous itemized deductions, which included investment advisory fees, were suspended starting in 2018, and the 2025 federal tax law made that suspension permanent (Public Law 119-21, Sec. 70110).
California did not conform. On the California return, expenses paid to produce taxable income or to manage property held for income can still be claimed as a miscellaneous itemized deduction, but only above 2% of AGI (FTB Schedule CA (540) instructions, lines 19 to 22). For the example family with AGI around $1.1 million, the first $22,000 of qualifying expenses produces no deduction at all, and California also limits itemized deductions at high incomes. In practice, the California benefit is usually small. Fees tied to retirement accounts are a separate question to review with your CPA.
Washington has no individual income tax for 2026, so there is no state income tax deduction to consider there (Washington DOR). That changes for high earners: a new 9.9% tax on AGI over $1 million takes effect January 1, 2028 (SB 6346), and how it will treat investment expenses is still pending DOR guidance.
Five questions to ask before you choose a fee model
- What exactly is billed? Get the list of accounts included in the fee, and whether your 401(k), stock plan account and 529s count.
- What is the total cost in dollars? Ask for this year’s fee, plus fund expenses and custodian costs, as one dollar figure. Form CRS includes the required statement that you “will pay fees and costs whether you make or lose money on your investments.”
- What is in scope? Tax projections, RSU and ESPP sale planning, estimated payments, estate document coordination, insurance review. If it is not written down, assume it is not included.
- How does the fee change? For AUM: the full tier schedule and whether it is blended. For flat fees: how and when the price is reviewed.
- How is the adviser paid, all in? Read Item 5 of their Form ADV Part 2 brochure and their Form CRS. You can look up any registered adviser on the SEC’s Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site.
Common mistakes high-income families make with advisory fees
- Comparing percentages instead of dollars. 0.75% sounds small. On $4 million it is $30,000 a year, every year.
- Ignoring what grows the base. With steady RSU vesting, an AUM fee can rise faster than the portfolio’s market return because new money is added each quarter.
- Paying for management and getting no planning. Many families with complex equity comp pay a large AUM fee and still do their own RSU withholding math every April.
- Not revisiting the arrangement. A fee model that fit at $1 million may not fit at $5 million. Review it when your balance or your needs change.
What to write down for your kids
Your children will not see your advisory agreement, but one day they may have to choose an adviser of their own. A one-page note explaining how you pay for advice, what you checked before signing, and why you chose that model turns a private contract into a lesson. As Kevin Luu puts it: “Your kids don’t need to inherit your portfolio. They need to inherit your decision-making process.” At Age Five Family Office™, we call that kind of note a Decision Memo, and it belongs in your family’s FamilyKnowledge® Library.
Frequently asked questions
Is a 1% AUM fee reasonable?
It depends on the balance and on what the fee buys. On $500,000 it is $5,000 a year. On $5 million it is $50,000 a year, and most schedules drop the rate at that size. Ask for the fee in dollars, list what is included, and compare it with a flat-fee quote for the same scope before deciding whether it is fair for your family.
What is the difference between AUM and AUA?
Assets under management (AUM) are accounts the adviser has authority to manage, usually held at their custodian. Assets under advisement (AUA) also include accounts they advise on but do not control, such as a 401(k) or company stock plan account. Some firms bill on both, so ask which accounts are in the fee base before you compare quotes.
Can I switch from an AUM adviser to a flat-fee adviser without selling investments?
Usually yes. Accounts can typically be transferred in kind between custodians, keeping the same holdings and cost basis. Selling in a taxable account can trigger capital gains, which California taxes as ordinary income (top rate 13.3% for 2025, the latest published schedule), so a transfer should be planned, not rushed. Check any prepaid-fee refund terms in the old agreement first.
Next step
Put your current or proposed advisory fee into dollars for this year, year 10 and year 20, using your own balance and expected savings, and compare it with a flat quote for the same written scope. If you want a second set of eyes on the numbers alongside your tax and equity comp picture, our investment and risk management and tax management pages explain how we work with families. For more on costs, see how much a wealth manager costs, average advisory management fees and how many advisers are fiduciaries.
This is general education, not individual advice. The right fee arrangement depends on your family’s full financial picture.
Kevin has advised high-income W-2 tech and biotech families since 2015, and leads the education-first Age Five Family Office from Brea, California.
Connect on LinkedIn → · About KevinThis is part of how we approach Investment & Risk Management for high-income W-2 families at Bright Advisers.
Keep reading