By Kevin Luu, Co-Founder and Chief Learning Officer. Reviewed on 2026-09-30.
International stocks are a reasonable part of a long-term portfolio, but not because anyone can predict that they will beat US stocks next year. US stocks have led for most of the last fifteen years, and in other long stretches (the 2000s are the usual example) international markets led instead. Holding both means you are not betting your family’s savings on which country wins the next decade.
For a high-income family in California or Washington, the more urgent question is usually different. If one parent works at Apple, Amazon or Gilead, a large share of the household’s net worth may already sit in one US company, on top of a US index fund that holds that same company. Before comparing US and international returns, it is worth measuring how much of your money is really riding on the US market and on your employer.
How US and international returns have compared, and why leadership rotates
Stock returns come from three sources: earnings growth, dividends, and changes in how much investors will pay for each dollar of earnings (valuation). For US investors there is a fourth source on the international side: currency. When the dollar weakens, foreign holdings are worth more in dollars; when it strengthens, they are worth less.
US outperformance in the 2010s and early 2020s came largely from a group of very large technology companies whose earnings grew fast and whose valuations rose. That is a real advantage, but part of it is already reflected in higher prices. International markets tend to have more banks, industrial firms and consumer brands, and different interest-rate and currency cycles. The two groups move together much of the time, but not always, and the gaps between them can last many years.
Two common claims about this comparison deserve correcting:
- Election-year patterns are not a useful basis for splitting money between countries. A handful of election years is far too small a sample to plan around.
- Currency risk does not need to be “managed” with hedging products for most long-term families. Over long periods currency moves tend to be a source of added variety, not a problem to trade around, and hedging adds cost.
Some readers ask whether international markets are “less efficient” and so easier to beat. Some smaller and emerging markets have less analyst coverage, but that has not reliably translated into better results for active funds after their higher fees. For most families, a low-cost broad international index fund is the simpler choice. Our guide on how much you should pay in investment fees shows why cost matters more than market selection over twenty years.
Why W-2 families with RSUs are often less diversified than they think
Equity compensation creates a double concentration. Your paycheck depends on one employer, your unvested RSUs depend on the same employer, and your vested shares often stay put because selling feels disloyal or simply never gets scheduled. Add a US total market or S&P 500 fund, which holds your employer’s stock again, and the portfolio can end up 90% or more tied to the US market, with a single company as the biggest line.
That matters because the risks overlap. A bad stretch for US technology stocks could hit your vested shares, your unvested grants, your bonus and possibly your job at the same time. International stocks are one of the few holdings that do not depend on any of those.
Worked example: a Seattle family and a Bay Area family with the same portfolio
Assumptions (illustrative only): married couple filing jointly, two children aged 4 and 8, household W-2 income of $1.1 million including RSU vests. Liquid investments of $4 million:
| Holding | Value | Share of portfolio |
|---|---|---|
| Vested employer shares (US tech company) | $1,400,000 | 35% |
| US S&P 500 index fund, taxable account | $1,900,000 | 47.5% |
| 401(k)s, US large-cap fund | $500,000 | 12.5% |
| International index fund | $200,000 | 5% |
| Total | $4,000,000 | 100% |
The family is 95% in US stocks, and more than a third of their money is in one company before counting unvested RSUs. Suppose they want to reach roughly 25% international over time. There are three ways to fund that, in order of tax cost.
1. Sell RSUs as they vest
RSUs are taxed as wages when the shares are delivered, and the amount taxed as wages becomes your cost basis. Selling shares right at vest usually produces little or no additional capital gain, so this is the cheapest source of cash for rebalancing. Note that the 22% flat federal supplemental withholding many employers apply to vests (an optional rate; 37% is mandatory on supplemental wages over $1 million in a calendar year, per IRS Publication 15) is often less than the tax owed at the 35% and 37% brackets, so set aside cash for the balance.
2. Redirect new savings and 401(k) contributions
New money and changes inside the 401(k) cost nothing in tax. Switching the 401(k) fund choice to include international is a trade inside a tax-deferred account.
3. Sell appreciated holdings in the taxable account
This is where California and Washington diverge. Say the family sells $200,000 of the S&P 500 fund with $120,000 of long-term gain, and has no other capital gains that year.
- Federal, both states: at their income, long-term gains fall in the 20% bracket (taxable income above $613,700 for joint filers in 2026) plus the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax (MAGI above $250,000). That is 23.8% of $120,000, or $28,560.
- California: California taxes capital gains as ordinary income, with no lower rate. Assuming California taxable income is already above $1 million before the sale (about $1.1 million), the marginal rate using 2025 brackets (the latest published) is 11.3% plus the 1% Behavioral Health Services Tax on income over $1 million, 12.3% in total. That adds about $14,760, for a combined bill of about $43,320.
- Washington: Washington’s 7% capital gains tax applies only to long-term gains above the standard deduction, $278,000 for 2025 (the latest published amount). With $120,000 of gain, the state tax is $0 and the total bill stays near $28,560.
The practical result: a California family typically leans harder on steps 1 and 2 and sells appreciated funds slowly, ideally paired with harvested losses. A Washington family has more room to rebalance in a single year, though that may change for high earners from 2028, when Washington’s new 9.9% income tax for households with AGI over $1 million takes effect (the Department of Revenue has not yet said how it will treat capital gains).
Tax details that change where international funds belong
International funds pay dividends from which foreign governments often withhold tax. In a taxable account, that withholding usually appears on your Form 1099-DIV and can be claimed as a foreign tax credit. The IRS lets you claim it without filing Form 1116 if your qualified foreign taxes are $600 or less on a joint return ($300 otherwise), all of the income is passive and reported on a payee statement, and you elect this method (IRS, Foreign Tax Credit). At the portfolio sizes in the example, especially after moving toward 25% international, foreign taxes may exceed $600, in which case Form 1116 is needed. Electing the simplified method also means unused foreign taxes cannot be carried to other years.
Because the credit is claimed through a taxable account’s 1099, many families hold some of their international allocation in the taxable brokerage account and use 401(k) space for bonds or other holdings. This is a placement decision to make with your tax preparer, not a rule.
The decision the family actually has to make
- Measure total exposure. Add vested shares, unvested RSUs, ESPP holdings and every fund. Know your real US and single-company percentages.
- Pick a target and a ceiling. For example: international at 20% to 30% of stocks, and employer stock at no more than a set share of net worth.
- Choose the funding order. RSU vests and new savings first, taxable sales last, with state tax in mind.
- Write it down. A one-page rule that says what you hold and why, so you do not abandon it after a year when one market wins.
Common mistakes
- Chasing whichever market led last year, then switching after it lags.
- Treating an S&P 500 fund as diversification when your employer is one of its largest holdings.
- Holding vested RSUs because of the tax on sale, when selling at vest usually triggers little extra gain.
- Buying single foreign stocks or narrow country funds instead of a broad, low-cost international index fund.
- Selling large appreciated positions in California in one year without checking the combined federal and state bill.
What to document for your kids
Children who see a portfolio but not the reasoning tend to copy the result, not the thinking. A short Decision Memo explaining why you hold international stocks even in years they trail, and how you decided when to sell company shares, is worth more to them than the account statement. As Kevin Luu, Co-Founder of Bright Advisers, puts it: “Your kids don’t need to inherit your portfolio. They need to inherit your decision-making process.” That memo belongs in your FamilyKnowledge® Library alongside your estate documents (see our family governance work).
Frequently asked questions
Are international stocks a good investment now?
No one can reliably time which region will lead next. The case for international stocks is diversification: different companies, sectors, interest-rate cycles and currencies. For a family whose income and equity grants depend on one US company, a steady allocation to a broad international index fund reduces the chance that one market or one employer decides the family’s outcome.
Is an S&P 500 fund enough on its own?
It holds about 500 large US companies, which is broad within the US but excludes the rest of the world and overlaps heavily with big-tech employers. If you already own a large block of your employer’s stock, an S&P 500 fund adds more of the same risk. Many families pair it with an international fund and, for bonds, a separate allocation. See our note on the 90/10 portfolio.
Should I hedge currency on international funds?
For long-term stock holdings, most families do not need to. Currency moves add variety to returns, and hedged funds usually cost more. Hedging matters more for money you will spend in dollars soon, which generally should not be in stocks at all. Short-term goals, such as a home down payment, belong in cash or short-term bonds.
Next step
List every holding, including unvested RSUs, and calculate your US and single-company percentages this week. If the numbers surprise you, our investment risk management and tax management teams at Age Five Family Office™ can map out a sale schedule as part of a Tax & Wealth Assessment. For more on allocation, see family office asset allocation.
This is general education, and the right move depends on the family’s full picture.
Kevin has advised high-income W-2 tech and biotech families since 2015, and leads the education-first Age Five Family Office from Brea, California.
Connect on LinkedIn → · About KevinThis is part of how we approach Investment & Risk Management for high-income W-2 families at Bright Advisers.
Keep reading