Flat vs Progressive Tax: What It Means on a $900K Paycheck

By Kevin Luu, Co-Founder and Chief Learning Officer. Reviewed on 2026-09-30.

A flat tax charges every taxable dollar the same rate, no matter how much you earn. A progressive tax charges a higher rate as income rises, but only on the dollars inside each higher bracket, so your average rate always stays below your top rate. The US federal income tax and California’s income tax are progressive; Social Security, Medicare, California SDI and Washington’s WA Cares premium are flat-rate taxes on wages.

For a two-earner household with $900,000 of W-2 pay and RSUs, the difference is not a civics question. It explains why your paycheck withholding looks fine all year and then leaves a five-figure balance in April, why your “37% bracket” does not mean you pay 37%, and why moving between California and Washington changes some taxes and not others.

Flat tax vs progressive tax in one table

Flat (proportional) tax Progressive tax
Rate One rate on every taxable dollar Rates step up in brackets as income rises
Average vs top rate Average rate equals the rate (before any cap or exemption) Average rate is always below the top marginal rate
Examples this family pays Medicare 1.45%, CA SDI 1.3%, WA Cares 0.58%, Social Security 6.2% up to a wage cap Federal income tax (10% to 37%), California income tax (top 13.3% for 2025), federal long-term capital gains (0%, 15%, 20%)
What drives your bill Total wages Taxable income after deductions, and where the last dollars land

Two common quiz questions, answered plainly. If a tax runs from 2% to 5% depending on your bracket, it is progressive, because the rate rises with income. And a flat tax is not the same as a regressive tax: a pure flat tax takes the same share from everyone. A flat tax becomes regressive when it stops at a cap, which is exactly what Social Security does.

How the federal brackets work on $900,000 of wages

Here is a worked example. Assumptions: married filing jointly, two earners at $450,000 each ($600,000 of combined salary and bonus plus $300,000 of RSU vests), both spouses defer the full $24,500 into a 401(k) for 2026, and the family takes the 2026 standard deduction of $32,200. Taxable income is $900,000 minus $49,000 minus $32,200, or $818,800. Bracket figures are from IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-32.

2026 MFJ bracket Income taxed in this bracket Tax
10% ($0 to $24,800) $24,800 $2,480
12% ($24,800 to $100,800) $76,000 $9,120
22% ($100,800 to $211,400) $110,600 $24,332
24% ($211,400 to $403,550) $192,150 $46,116
32% ($403,550 to $512,450) $108,900 $34,848
35% ($512,450 to $768,700) $256,250 $89,687.50
37% (over $768,700) $50,100 $18,537
Total $818,800 $225,120.50

The family is “in the 37% bracket”, but only $50,100 is taxed at 37%. Federal income tax is about 27.5% of taxable income and about 25.0% of gross wages. If every dollar were taxed at 37%, the bill would be $302,956, about $77,800 more. That gap is the whole point of a progressive system.

The marginal rate still matters most for decisions. The next $10,000 of RSU vest or bonus costs $3,700 in federal income tax, and each $10,000 of 401(k) deferral or other pre-tax reduction saves $3,700. Your average rate tells you what you paid. Your marginal rate tells you what a choice is worth.

The flat taxes on the same paycheck

Payroll taxes for 2026 run alongside the brackets. Social Security is 6.2% on wages up to $184,500 per earner; Medicare is 1.45% on all wages, plus a 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax on joint wages over $250,000 (IRS Publication 15, IRS Additional Medicare Tax Q&A). California adds State Disability Insurance at 1.3% of all wages with no cap for 2026 (EDD).

2026 employee payroll tax, California $900,000 household (two earners at $450,000) $150,000 household (one earner)
Social Security (6.2% to $184,500 each) $22,878 $9,300
Medicare (1.45%, no cap) $13,050 $2,175
Additional Medicare (0.9% over $250,000 joint) $5,850 $0
CA SDI (1.3%, no cap) $11,700 $1,950
Total, as share of wages $53,478 (5.9%) $13,425 (9.0%)

The base 1.45% Medicare tax and SDI are truly flat (the 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax adds a second step above $250,000 of joint wages). Social Security is flat up to the wage base and then drops to zero, so as a share of pay it is regressive at the top. Together, these “flat” taxes take a smaller share of a $900,000 household’s wages than of a $150,000 household’s, even though the dollar amount is four times larger.

California vs Washington: which taxes change when you move

California taxes wages with a progressive schedule. The 2026 schedules had not been published by the Franchise Tax Board as of this review, so this uses the 2025 joint schedule: 9.3% from $145,448, 10.3% from $742,958, 11.3% from $891,542, 12.3% above $1,485,906, plus a 1% Behavioral Health Services Tax on taxable income over $1,000,000, for a top rate of 13.3% (FTB 2025 rate schedules). Assuming California taxable income of $850,000 for our family, tax before credits is $61,972.37 plus 10.3% of $107,042, or about $72,998. That is roughly 8.6% of California taxable income, against a 10.3% marginal rate. California has no lower rate for capital gains, so RSU shares sold at a gain are taxed on the same progressive schedule as wages (FTB).

Washington has no individual income tax for 2026 (WA DOR), so the same $900,000 of wages carries no state income tax. Washington’s state-level taxes on this family are mostly flat in design:

  • WA Cares: 0.58% of all wages, no cap, or $5,220 on $900,000 (WA Cares Fund).
  • Capital gains tax: 7% on long-term gains above a standard deduction ($278,000 for 2025, the latest published), rising to 9.9% on taxable gains over $1,000,000 (WA DOR capital gains tax). A flat rate with a large exemption and a second tier is mildly progressive in practice.
  • From January 1, 2028, a new 9.9% income tax applies to individuals and joint filers with AGI over $1,000,000 (SB 6346). DOR has not yet issued full guidance on the income definition or how it interacts with the capital gains tax (WA DOR FAQ). A Seattle household with large RSU vests should plan for 2028, not assume “no income tax” forever.

The federal brackets, Social Security, Medicare and the Additional Medicare Tax are identical in both states. So the marginal cost of the next $10,000 of RSU income for our example family in 2026 is about $5,095 in California (37% federal, 10.3% state, 1.45% plus 0.9% Medicare, 1.3% SDI) and about $3,993 in Washington (37% federal, 2.35% Medicare, 0.58% WA Cares).

Why a flat withholding rate on RSUs leaves a balance due

This is where flat and progressive collide for equity-paid families. Employers may withhold federal tax on RSU vests and bonuses at a flat 22% supplemental rate, rising to a mandatory 37% only on supplemental wages over $1,000,000 in the calendar year (IRS Publication 15). The actual tax is progressive.

In our example, the $300,000 of RSU income sits on top of salary, from $518,800 to $818,800 of taxable income. The tax on that slice is $249,900 at 35% ($87,465) plus $50,100 at 37% ($18,537), or $106,002. Flat 22% withholding takes $66,000. The shortfall is about $40,000 of federal tax, before any state gap. Withholding is not the tax owed.

The decisions to make each year:

  1. Estimate your top two brackets in January, using expected vests at a conservative share price.
  2. Choose how to close the gap: higher W-4 withholding on salary, quarterly estimated payments, or selling extra shares at vest if your plan allows a higher withholding election.
  3. Recheck in September, after most vests are known, while there is still time to adjust withholding.

Related reading: how federal tax works at $200,000 of income, and ways to reduce modified adjusted gross income.

Common mistakes high earners make with tax rates

  • Treating the top bracket as the average rate. It overstates the cost of earning more and can lead to bad calls, like turning down a raise or a relocation package.
  • Using the average rate to value a deduction. A 401(k) deferral or a charitable gift saves at your marginal rate, not your average rate.
  • Assuming capital gains are always taxed lower. Federally, long-term gains get 0%, 15% or 20% (20% above $613,700 of taxable income for joint filers in 2026), plus the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax over $250,000 of MAGI (IRS). In California the state rate on gains is the same as on wages.
  • Forgetting payroll taxes are uncapped. Medicare, CA SDI and WA Cares keep applying to every RSU dollar, even after Social Security stops.

What to write down for your kids

Children see the outcomes of tax decisions (the house, the move, the year you held shares instead of selling) but rarely the reasoning. A one-page note on how your family thinks about marginal rates, why you defer into a 401(k), and how you decided between California and Washington is the kind of entry that belongs in a FamilyKnowledge® Library. As Kevin Luu puts it: “Your kids don’t need to inherit your portfolio. They need to inherit your decision-making process.”

When your children are old enough for an allowance, the bracket table above is also a good first lesson: a raise never pushes the dollars you already earn into a higher bracket, because only the extra dollars pay the higher rate. Our Age Five Wealth Education work covers how to turn ideas like this into short, age-appropriate conversations.

FAQ

What is the main difference between a flat tax rate and a progressive tax rate?

A flat tax applies one rate to every taxable dollar, so everyone pays the same percentage. A progressive tax applies higher rates to higher slices of income, so higher earners pay a larger percentage overall. In 2026, the federal income tax uses seven brackets from 10% to 37%, while Medicare uses a flat 1.45% on all wages.

Is a flat tax the same as a regressive tax?

No. A pure flat tax takes the same share of income from everyone, which is called proportional. A regressive tax takes a smaller share from higher earners. A flat tax becomes regressive when it has a cap, as Social Security does: 6.2% applies only to the first $184,500 of each worker’s 2026 wages, so the share falls as pay rises above that level.

Does moving to Washington mean I pay a flat tax instead?

For 2026, Washington has no wage income tax, so you avoid California’s progressive income tax and SDI but still pay the same progressive federal income tax. Washington taxes some long-term capital gains at 7% to 9.9% and, from January 1, 2028, will apply a 9.9% income tax to individuals and joint filers with AGI over $1,000,000. Residency rules for leaving California are strict and worth reviewing before a move.

Next step

Take your last pay stub and your expected 2026 RSU vests, and compare what has been withheld with the bracket math above. If the gap is large, or you are weighing a move between California and Washington, our tax management team at the Age Five Family Office™ can run the numbers with you in a Tax & Wealth Assessment; see also our retirement and employee benefits work on 401(k) and RSU decisions.

This is general education, and the right move depends on the family’s full picture.

Kevin Luu, Co-Founder and Chief Learning Officer of Bright Advisers
Written by
Co-Founder and Chief Learning Officer, Bright Advisers

Kevin has advised high-income W-2 tech and biotech families since 2015, and leads the education-first Age Five Family Office from Brea, California.

Connect on LinkedIn →  · About Kevin

Table of Contents

Question 1 of 3

How much do you expect to pay in taxes this year?

Include federal, state, and local, just your best estimate.

A Under $150,000
B $150,000 – $199,999
C $200,000 – $299,999
D $300,000+
Question 2 of 3

What is your current annual household income?

Your typical annual income before taxes over the next few years.

A Under $750,000
B $750,000 – $999,999
C $1,000,000 – $2,999,999
D $3,000,000+
Question 3 of 3

Where does most of your income come from?

Choose all that apply. Focus on where ~80% of your income is taxed today.

✓ W-2 employee (salary, bonus, RSUs)
✓ Business owner (LLC, S-Corp, partnership)
✓ Rental / real estate
✓ Other
Your fit

Full assessment · 1 of 5

What does your current CPA relationship look like?

Be honest. This is where most of the opportunity hides.

A Tax preparation once a year
B Planning & preparation throughout the year
C I don't currently work with a CPA
Full assessment · 2 of 5

Have you ever had formal tax projections done?

Forward-looking modeling of your taxes, not just filing last year's return.

A Yes, recently
B Yes, but not in the last 2 years
C No
Full assessment · 3 of 5

Which strategies are you already using?

Choose all that apply.

✓ 401(k) / employer plan
✓ Backdoor Roth IRA
✓ Health Savings Account (HSA)
✓ Mega Backdoor Roth 401(k)
✓ Deferred Compensation
✓ Donor-Advised Fund
✓ None of these
Full assessment · 4 of 5

Do you have children under 18?

This opens up family-governance and generational planning strategies.

A Yes
B No
Full assessment · 5 of 5

If we showed you legal strategies that save more than they cost, would you act?

No pressure, this just helps us tailor your results.

A Yes, if the value is clear
B Maybe, I'd want to understand more
C Not right now
Almost done

Where should we send your full results?

We'll prepare your personalized savings breakdown and reach out to walk you through it.

Your information is private. Reviewed by an SEC-Registered Fiduciary (Bright Advisers, a DBA of Lifeworks Advisors, LLC · CRD# 288255).
Your results

estimated potential tax savings

    Kevin Luu

    "Thank you for taking the time. I've helped hundreds of high-earning families keep more of what they make, and from what you shared, I'm confident there's real opportunity here. I'll personally see you at our meeting."

    Kevin Luu · Co-Founder and Chief Learning Officer, Bright Advisers